Many fans thought he would soon join WWE, given that his wife, Rhea Ripley, is a prominent star in the company. Especially with the storyline Mami is currently involved in, Matthews would have been a great addition. However, it will be interesting to see what the future holds for the 35-year-old wrestler.
The reports of Buddy Matthews signing with the Jacksonville-based company certainly caught people's attention. Some fans stated that both he and Rhea Ripley were making big decisions for their future. Other fans were confused at first but understood his decision after witnessing Andrade's treatment in WWE.
One fan expressed the desire to see the 35-year-old star tag team with fellow AEW wrestler PAC. Another fan recalled the disastrous storyline he was involved in with Rey Mysterio's daughter, Aaliyah Mysterio, and respected his decision. Here are some of the top reactions from fans: