Amid ongoing tensions linked to the Iran conflict, internal divisions in Pakistan appear to be deepening. A controversy has erupted after Shia leaders alleged that they were publicly humiliated during a high-profile Iftar gathering, sparking outrage within the community.
Allegations of insult at Iftar gathering
The incident reportedly took place on March 19 during an Iftar event attended by senior Shia clerics. According to multiple accounts, members of the community were subjected to disrespectful remarks, leading to widespread anger.
Mohammad Shifa Najafi, a prominent Shia religious leader, claimed that the community faced 'serious humiliation' during the event. He said some attendees were told that if they had strong sympathies for Iran, they should 'go and live there.'
Army Chief accused of harsh remarks
As per a report by CNN-News18, Pakistan's Army Chief Asim Munir allegedly reprimanded top Shia scholars in a public setting.
Sources cited in the report claimed that Munir spoke for nearly an hour in what was described as a one-sided address. During this time, Shia clerics were reportedly not given an opportunity to present their concerns or ask questions.
Leaders react strongly
Following the event, Mohammad Shifa Najafi said he responded to the remarks by pointing out that Muhammad Ali Jinnah himself belonged to the Shia community.
Another cleric, Hasnain Abbas Gardez, criticised the tone of the Army Chief, calling it inappropriate for someone holding such a high constitutional position. He described the remarks as dismissive and lacking dignity.
Shia leaders who attended the event also alleged that they were repeatedly labelled as 'loyal to Iran' and accused of acting against Pakistan's interests. Some even said heated arguments broke out during the gathering.
Allama Nazir Abbas Taqvi reportedly attempted to intervene multiple times during the speech to initiate a dialogue but expressed surprise at the overall conduct.
No follow-up meeting held
According to reports, after the hour-long session, attendees were told there would be another round of discussions after dinner. However, Shia scholars claimed they waited for a long time, but no further meeting took place as the Army Chief left the venue.
This added to the frustration among attendees, many of whom said they felt deeply disrespected and sidelined.
Community voices anger and concern
In the aftermath of the incident, several Shia leaders expressed that the community feels increasingly marginalised, with some saying they are being treated as second-class citizens.
Responding strongly, leaders asserted that their loyalty lies firmly with Islam and Pakistan, not with any foreign nation. They also highlighted the historical role of the Shia community in Pakistan's formation, noting that key figures in the independence movement, including leaders of the Muslim League, had Shia roots.
They further accused the Pakistani establishment of ignoring the community's long-standing religious ties with holy sites in Mecca, Medina, Iraq and Iran.