On Wednesday, March 11, 2026, the show became the target of heavy trolling across social media platforms, with viewers calling out its central romantic plot between a 16-year-old girl and an adult man.

The Controversy: “Grooming in the Name of a Social Message”

The show follows the story of Seher Baig, a 16-year-old who has not yet appeared for her 10th-grade exams, and her marriage to Mahid (played by Parth Samthaan), a man significantly older than her.

Social message in the form of Grooming/Pedophile
byu/ProfessionalNorth566 inIndianTellyTalk

• Reddit Backlash: A viral Reddit thread titled “Social message in the form of Grooming/Pedophile” has become a hub for critics. One viewer noted, “She didn't even write her 10th exam yet… and they are showing romance,” while others questioned the writers for depicting a minor in a romantic track rather than making the character at least 18.
• Cultural Representation: Some viewers also argued that the show's portrayal of its Muslim backdrop is inaccurate and does not properly represent Islamic values, despite the production team’s focus on Urdu diction and nuances.

Producer's Defense

Producer Richa Yamini has defended the casting of Parth Samthaan, noting his maturity since his Kaisi Yeh Yaariaan days. She told IWMBuzz that Parth brings the necessary layers to Mahid's character. The team has reportedly put significant effort into staying authentic to the story’s cultural setting, emphasizing that Parth has completely transformed into the role of Mahid.